Darren Jones
Experience and design leadership — Berlin

OpinionNovember 20264 min readDraft

When making is cheap, taste is the work

AI makes it easy to produce a hundred options before lunch. Knowing which one is right, and saying why, is now the skill that counts.

The short version

  • Making used to be the slow part. Now it's the fast part.
  • With endless options, choosing well is the rare skill.
  • Taste isn't a gift. It's built through reference, critique and repetition.
  • A leader's job is to set the bar and protect the time it takes to judge.

01

The slow part moved

When I started, making was slow. A layout took a day. A film took a month. Because it was slow, we thought hard before we began, and most of the judgement happened up front.

Since 2023 I've watched that flip on real accounts. A team can have fifty directions on the wall by the afternoon. Images, copy, layouts and working prototypes arrive faster than anyone can look at them properly.

The slow part didn't disappear. It moved to after the making, to the moment someone has to say: this one, not those.

02

More options, same hours

A pile of options looks like progress. Often it's the opposite. Fifty average ideas take longer to review than five good ones, and they wear out the people reviewing them.

The tools gave us more to choose from. They didn't give us more hours to choose in.

I've seen teams ship the option that was least wrong, because nobody had the energy left to ask for the one that was right. It looks finished and has the shine of care. It says nothing, and customers feel that even when they can't name it.

03

Taste can be taught

People talk about taste as if you're born with it. I don't believe that. In more than twenty years of leading design teams I've watched people build it, and it's built the same way every time:

  • Reference. Looking at a lot of very good work, from outside your field as well as inside it.
  • Critique. Saying out loud why something works, in words someone else can argue with.
  • Repetition. Making the call, living with the result, and making it again.
  • Closeness. Knowing the customer and the business well enough to know what the work is for.

None of these can be skipped, and no tool does them for you. What a tool can do is give you far more to practise on.

04

What leaders have to protect

If judgement is the work now, leaders have to make room for it. That comes down to a few unglamorous habits.

Set the bar early, with examples, so the team knows what they're choosing towards. Ask for fewer options and better reasons. Keep critique in the diary when the deadline is close. That's when it gets dropped, and when it's needed most.

Above all, keep juniors in the room. If tools do the making and only seniors do the choosing, nobody learns to choose. The teams I'm proudest of were stronger when I left, and that only happens when judgement is shared.

05

Make it, then decide

One habit I keep: make the thing, then decide. Don't debate a brief for weeks. Put something real on the table and react to it. AI makes that habit far easier.

The second half is the one that matters now. Anyone can make it. The value is in deciding, and in explaining the decision to a client, a board or a customer.

That was always the job of a creative leader. It's just easier to see now that everything else got faster.

Darren JonesIndependent experience and design leader in Berlin. Before that, four years as Group Experience Director at MRM.

Talk about this →

Up next

Opinion · 3 min readWhat AI really changes in interface design

AI used to sit at the edge of the design process. Now it sits in the middle. Here is what that changes for the work, the team and the people who use what we make.

Opinion · 5 min readYour next customer is an agent

More of the customer journey is being done by software acting for people. That changes what a brand is, and what an experience team is for.